.png)
Key Points
- A former Virginia law librarian sued the Department of Education in May 2026 after it denied two of her PSLF applications and never ruled on a third, filed in December 2022.
- The Justice Department argued she had to prove most of her own job duties were public service, a test that appears in no version of the PSLF rules.
- ED’s records show 210 eligible payments on her loans, but only 81 count because the department won’t credit her nine years at the Fairfax Bar Association.
Melissa Scheeren worked at the Fairfax Bar Association’s public law library and pro bono center from March 2008 to February 2017. She later worked for Arlington County, the Library of Congress and the University of Virginia, all government employers. She consolidated her older FFEL loans into a Direct Consolidation Loan in November 2021 using the Biden Limited PSLF Waiver, and ED now credits 210 eligible payments on that loan.
In May 2026, she sued the Department of Education and MOHELA (PDF File) arguing she was owed Public Service Loan Forgiveness when she applied in September 2022.
One of the first issues is that a 501(c)(3) nonprofit qualifies automatically. Other nonprofits, like the bar association, which is a 501(c)(6), have to show that they provide a listed public service. While Scheeren’s employment does meet this and the DOJ agrees, it appears to be one of the first holdups.
The second issue appears to be related to the limited PSLF waiver, consolidation, and payment counts. A July 2025 ED letter in the court record shows 210 eligible payments on her loans and 81 qualifying payments. Regardless of the reasons for the error, it appears she is entitled to have her loans forgiven.
Scheeren says she has paid $16,140.71 on loans that should have been discharged, and about $40,000 remains on her account. She is asking the court to reverse the denial and process the forgiveness she says she’s owed.
Save For Later
Would you like to save this?
Why It Matters
The government’s defense rests on a reading of PSLF that ED itself has rejected. In an August 19, 2026 motion for summary judgment (PDF File), the Justice Department wrote that Scheeren “was required to prove that most of her employment with the FBA was in one of the enumerated fields.”
PSLF has never measured the borrower’s job. That’s why a career in public service can lead to forgiveness for any full-time worker at a qualifying employer, whatever the role.
The government’s own exhibits say the same thing. In a letter to Sen. Tim Kaine (PDF File) about Scheeren’s case, Federal Student Aid wrote that eligibility “is not about the work a borrower does but is based on who their employer is.”
DOJ filed that letter with its own motion, and it matches how Public Service Loan Forgiveness has worked since 2008.
How Did ED Handle Her PSLF Applications?
ED and MOHELA denied two applications with reasons that contradict, and the third has never been decided. She also followed the PSLF paperwork steps borrowers are told to take, including reconsideration requests, complaints and an ombudsman escalation.
One Borrower’s PSLF Record 2008–2026
| Date | What Happened | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Mar. 2008–Feb. 2017 | Works full-time at the Fairfax Bar Association’s public law library and pro bono center | 108 PaymentsMade during these years, by her count. ED counts none of them. |
| Apr. 2018–Present | Works full-time for government employers: Arlington County, the Library of Congress and the University of Virginia | 81 PaymentsCredited by ED as of July 2026 |
| June 2019 | Reaches her 120th qualifying payment, by her count | 120 PaymentsEligible for forgiveness if the bar association years count |
| Nov. 4, 2021 | Consolidates older FFEL loans into a Direct Consolidation Loan during the Limited PSLF Waiver | 210 EligibleED later credits 210 eligible payments on the new loan |
| Sept. 2, 2022 | Files PSLF Application 1 with the association’s bylaws | DeniedOct. 24, 2022, calling the nonprofit “a for-profit organization” |
| Oct. 24, 2022 | Files PSLF Application 2 with bylaws and public website materials | DeniedOct. 27, 2023, saying it “does not provide a public service” |
| Dec. 12, 2022 | Files PSLF Application 3, adding articles of incorporation and a letter from the executive director | Never DecidedStill open |
| July 13, 2023 | Files Reconsideration Request 1 | DeniedFive days later |
| Nov. 13, 2023 | Files Reconsideration Request 2 with certified corporate records | DeniedMarch 27, 2024, with the same one-line reason |
| Jan. 30, 2024 | Files a complaint with the Department of Education | ClosedFeb. 27, 2025, with a general form letter |
| May 13, 2026 | Sues ED and MOHELA in federal court | PendingBefore Judge Christopher Cooper |
| Where She Stands | 81 qualifying payments credited, 189 if the bar association years count | 120 needed for forgiveness |
Source: Scheeren v. Department of Education court filings. The College Investor.
